Real john here, the market is changing (again). I’ve been through it all, building on AS/400 and then the internet happened… then building on the web, then client-server vs server-client, then SaaS, containers are the answer, cloud is the answer, and now AI. I’ve pivoted more in technology than Jalen Brunson in triple coverage. The ability to pivot hasn’t changed, the speed of of the pivot and adapting to the market is what is new this time. It’s actually fun again. But there is a lot of unemployment going on right now and a job gets posted on LinkedIn and has over 100 applicants in an hour. It is difficult for applicants to get seen and even more difficult for recruiters and HR to cut through the noise. This week is about recruiters and how valuable they are in the market right now.
A recruiter who only forwards my résumé has a problem.
I can do that.
The recruiter I want to talk to understands what a company actually needs and can explain why my experience deserves a closer look. They can also tell me when it doesn’t.
I’ve been thinking about this as AI makes it easier to produce applications and harder to know what deserves attention. I think good recruiters have an opportunity here. Their value depends on the judgment they add.
And that puts some responsibility on the rest of us, too.
Everyone can produce a better looking application
On October 20, Greenhouse published a candidate survey with an awkward combination of findings. Among its 1,200 U.S. respondents, 77% said they had used AI in their job search during the past year. And 81% said they had been rejected from at least one job without speaking to anyone at the company, human or AI. The survey details are here.
That doesn’t tell us who made those rejection decisions or why. A rejection email is not evidence that a robot rejected you.
It does describe a frustrating situation: people have more help presenting themselves, yet many still never get a conversation.
I understand the temptation to respond with more volume. Another résumé version. Another batch of applications. Another tool that promises to get past the tool on the other side.
Eventually, somebody still has to answer a fairly ordinary question:
Can this person do the work we need done?
A useful introduction contains a reason
Imagine a company hiring an engineering leader because its releases keep slipping.
One candidate has a polished résumé listing strategy, transformation, stakeholder management, and approximately every other phrase available on LinkedIn.
Another can explain how they helped a team find where work was getting stuck, what they changed, what improved, and what they would do differently.
The second person has given a recruiter something to investigate.
A good recruiter can connect that experience to the company’s problem. They can ask whether the candidate actually owned the decision. They can find out whether the company needs a hands-on leader, someone who develops managers, or someone willing to challenge an impossible roadmap.
Those are different jobs. They can have the same title.
That is where I see the value. Someone who understands both sides can make a useful case for a conversation, including the gaps that still need checking.
Forwarding a résumé with “great candidate” attached is a much smaller contribution. Excellent. Great at what?
Applications still work
I don’t want to turn this into advice to abandon job applications and spend your life collecting introductions.
Ashby’s April 2026 recruiter productivity report analyzed more than 109 million applications and 247,000 jobs from January 2021 through March 2026. In that dataset, inbound applicants accounted for 52% of hires in the first quarter of 2026. Referrals and sourced candidates had declined as a share of hires. Read Ashby’s report.
That’s a useful correction to the idea that nobody gets hired by applying anymore.
It’s also a reminder to keep the claims straight. Those figures describe Ashby’s customer data. They don’t establish your odds of getting hired, prove that referrals cause better outcomes, or explain any particular rejection.
I would keep applying to roles that fit. I would also put more effort into making that fit easy to understand, whether the first reader is a recruiter, a hiring manager, or someone reviewing a direct application.
Give someone enough to work with
If I’m asking a person to introduce me, I owe them more than a résumé and “let me know if you hear of anything.”
I would give them a short explanation they can evaluate:
The work I want to do. Name the kind of problem, team, and responsibility. A title alone leaves a lot unanswered.
A relevant example. Describe the situation, my contribution, and the result. Use a real number if I have one. Explain the outcome plainly if I don’t.
Something they can check. A public project, a permitted work sample, or a reference who has agreed to speak.
The limits. Be honest about experience I don’t have and what I would need to learn.
That can fit in a few paragraphs. Nobody needs a forty-slide personal branding exercise.
AI can help organize the material, find vague claims, and ask the uncomfortable follow-up questions before another person does. I would use it for that. I would check every claim before attaching my name.
The goal is to give someone enough substance to decide whether an introduction makes sense.
Hiring leaders have work to do too
If I’m hiring, I can’t ask a recruiter to find the right person while giving them an impossible wish list and a job title.
I need to explain what this person must accomplish, which experience matters, and where I can accept a learning curve. I need to agree on how we’ll assess the evidence.
I also need a way for people outside my network to show what they can do. Familiarity can feel like confidence without telling me much about ability. Referrals deserve evaluation, not a free pass. Direct applicants deserve a fair route into the same process.
A recruiter earns my trust by improving that judgment. Sometimes that means bringing me someone whose résumé I would have overlooked. Sometimes it means challenging the role I thought I needed.
This week, I’d take one role I’m pursuing or one role I’m trying to fill and write down why a particular person might succeed in it.
If all I can produce is a list of adjectives, I still have work to do.
Work with me
If you’d like to work together, visit Startups and Code.




the line about "great candidate" with no reason attached is the whole problem in one sentence. the words used on the resume, when read by a recruiter or ai, may look like a match. but where did that experience come from? was it learned? was it used and applied successfully? were mistakes made and if so, what changed afterward? the four-part intro is perfect, if it is reads and filters on it. the story behind the person matters. good piece, John!